Hi there.
This is Alex.
Whenever
politicians and greens talk about alternative energy, the list usually goes
wind, solar, and tidal power. But how
real is tidal power? Where will it
happen and when?
This week
on Radio Ecoshock you'll hear Martin Burger, CEO of a tidal power company
called Blue Energy. He spoke to the New
Energy Movement in Vancouver on January 26th, 2009.
In fact,
Martin went further. He explained four
other neglected new energy sources, the best and most intriguing from a survey
of 500 he's examined over the past two decades. I'll add those as time allows.
And, as
promised in last week's show, we'll consider how new ways of living appear in a
society. Burger says money cannot bring
the next wave. It is a problem of
consciousness, how we function as big groups, like the flocks and schools of
other animals.
Along the
way, I'll toss in a few facts about installations around the world, the current
state of tidal power.
How about
this one. Did you know that days used
to be much shorter here on Earth? Like
21.9 hours, just 620 million years ago, instead of 24? Just pumping all that sea water into the
bays and narrows of the world uses up mechanical energy that causes the world
to spin. The tides are slowing down the
planet. The 26 hour day is coming. But don't toss out your clocks just yet -
that will be another 600 million years from now.
As we'll
hear from Martin Burger, this immense power can be harnessed to create giant streams
of electricity. The initial building
cost is high, but the long-term maintenance costs are quite low. The impact on the local ecology varies with
the design. Martin will be describing a
"tidal fence" of spinning rotors, built into a bridge perhaps. It's a big dream, but there are signs tidal
power is beginning to lift off in various parts of the world.
I'm going
to pick out the tidal info from Martin's speech at Simon Fraser University,
Vancouver.
[First
intro to 15 minute mark]
That is
Martin Burger, from http://www.blueenergy.com/. In this Radio Ecoshock special on tidal
power, we're going to skip ahead to what we came for. More on this powerful green energy source, from Martin's speech
to the New Energy Movement Canada in January 2009.
[Next
tidal clip]
This is
Radio Ecoshock, I'm Alex Smith and we're talking tidal power. Coming up, we'll here more from Martin
Burger as he addresses the New Energy Movement Canada - with good technologies
languishing under the regime of oil and coal.
First, I'd like to take a spin around the world,
to find tidal power in action. As
any Google search will tell you, humans have been harnessing the tides since
ancient times. The Romans did it, and
so did people in Medieval Europe, even making tidal rotors to drive grain
mills.
We could
still drive machinery with the tides, but the real goal now is electricity and
lots of it. Basically at least three
types of tide machines have been built, at least in prototypes. Case one: There are barricades which allow
the tide in, and then hold the water back for gradual release through the
turbines. These are the most
ecologically damaging to build and operate.
We can
look at one of the first real commercial tidal electric plants, built on the Rance River in France, back in
1966. To build it, the engineers had to
construct two dams on either side of the site, completely blocking the river
for a long time. Some species died off,
to be replaced by others after the river flow was somewhat restored. The project was expensive for the time, but
over the following decades, it has proved very cheap to maintain. The Rance River tidal project more than paid
back it's cost in electricity generated.
But most of us would find the ecological costs too high to bear, these
days.
Martin
Burger's designs are a second case, which are called tidal fences. They do not require a complete dam of the
local water flows. The electricity is only generated about 18
hours a day. That's because there
are two high tides, and two low, in each 24 hours, with about an hour and a
half of "slack tide" - the time when the water isn't moving much
either way. Still, with tidal tables,
this slack time is predictable years in advance. And tidal power is much more stable than either wind or solar,
which can vary with the weather.
The least ecologically damaging proposals call for the equivalent of wind turbines built on shallow ocean floors, turned by the tides. These would not be visible.
Proponents
of both tidal fences and turbines claim than neither marine mammals nor fish would be hurt by these installations. Burger said the rotors move slowly enough
that fish find the equivalent of a revolving door to a department store. Even larger fish, like salmon, can maneuver
their way through, he says, but during a major run, the rotors could be shut
down. There are also plans to let both
ships and large mammals pass through specially designed locks, located near the
normal traffic ways.
I don't
know enough to judge these claims - and the ecological impact of tidal power is
still being studied in various labs and universities. There is a worry about imposing our energy needs on the sea. What are the unforeseen impacts?
Still,
the vision of using the tides, instead of wrecking the atmosphere, seems very
promising.
Where is it?
There are
only about 40 places in the world where the tides are strong enough to generate
economic power. These have been pretty
well mapped out, at least for existing tech.
The United States has fewer tidal opportunities than
Canada, the UK, Russia, or even Australia.
Frankly,
there isn't much tide power going on in the U.S. As my San Francisco listeners know, there has been a proposal to
harness the tides running under the Golden Gate Bridge. The plan has stalled so far, but may happen
if financing and approval show up.
There has
been a prototype running since 2007 in the East River in New York City. The blades of the first model broke off, but
a stronger version was installed in September 2008. There is another test of a prototype near Eastport Maine.
We've
already heard about proposals to install tide turbines on Canada's
West Coast, and Puget Sound in the U.S. The famous Bay of Fundy on Canada's East Coast is also a good
contender. O yeah, and the Nova Scotia
Power Corporation also opened the Annapolis Royal Generating Station in 1984.
A company called Marine Current Turbines has installed a big 1 megawatt plus generator at Strangford Lough in North Ireland. The Wikipedia entry for tidal power says this is the first commercial scale device installed anywhere in the world. But the installation in the Rance River, France was built decades before that.
Dr. A. M.
Gorlov is offering a helical rotor type tide generator. Martin Burger disputes the originality of
the design, which is entering a pilot project in South Korea now. Gorlov has also claimed that turbines
running in the Gulf Stream could power all of North America.
Russia claims a 12 megawatt tidal project
is being constructed at Kislaya Guba with orthogonal turbines. China is experimenting with tide projects
large and small.
There was also a commercial scale trial of tidal power in Australia, off the Gold Coast of Queensland in 2002. The government also plans a combination desalinization and tidal power demonstration plant near Brisbane.
Many
other countries, from Norway through Italy to New Zealand, are seriously
considering tidal power, or already experimenting with it. But other than the Northern Ireland
installation, I think it's fair to say we don't yet have a big tidal generating
station operating anywhere in the world.
It's not vaporware, but tidal power isn't something we can rely on, in
the near term - unless climate change and energy prices drive governments and
corporations into serious action.
That
leads back to the question asked by many, including Senator John Kerry to Al
Gore in his January Senate testimony: why haven't these alternative energies
really taken off? Yes there has been a
solid block of lobby money, endless lobby money, from the old oil, gas and coal
industries. But there could be more. We don't yet understand what makes humans,
all of us, change.
So before
we examine some of the other technical contenders for better energy, with more
from Martin Burger, let's listen again to last week's clip. Burger calls on the vision of Einstein: that
everything is really a field of frozen or slowed energy. You and I are fields of atoms that are
somehow held together in a field. And
collectively we interact to project a larger field into time.
I want to
hear that one again.
[Burger
clip]
So all
the money in the world, even from Obama's dream, isn't likely to bring us tidal power,
and other significant energy changes, unless you and I can envision this
sustainable future. Until we the
experience of that hundredth monkey, the turning tide in the minds of millions
of humans.
I believe it can happen, even though we don't yet understand how. Some day, no matter what troubles arise, our energy will be drawn from the pull of the sun and moon on our oceans.
I'm Alex
Smith, and this is Radio Ecoshock.
We'll continue now with more from Martin Burger, CEO of Blue Energy, a
tidal power company. Speaking to the
New Energy Movement Canada, Burger explores the top tier of almost lost energy
alternatives he's encountered over the past couple of decades. This is from a seeker who looked pretty well
everywhere for energy answers.
[radio
discussion of other engine technologies, including the strange story of Stanley
Meyer, who was allegedly murdered after his discovery of using water to power a
car…]
That's
all the time we have this week. You
have been listening to a talk by Martin Burger. Find his website at www.blueenergy.com and check out
newenergymovement.ca for more ideas.
The recording was made by Alex Smith in Vancouver on January 26th, 2009.
Thanks
for donating your time and brain. What
do you think - will tidal power run the next civilization?